Shade cloth is rated by the percentage of light it blocks, so 50 percent cloth transmits about half the light that falls on it. That rating is a nominal figure measured on new material at a specific angle, and real transmission varies with sun angle, cloth tension and how dirty the cloth has become, so treat the percentage as a class rather than a precise value.
The reason a single figure for the whole house is usually wrong is that crops differ by a factor of five in the light they want. A tomato canopy will use everything a summer sky provides and asks only that leaf temperature stays survivable. A tray of cuttings with no roots cannot transpire fast enough to cool itself and will scorch at a third of that light.
| Crop group | Summer shade percentage | Target DLI, mol/m2/day |
|---|---|---|
| Tomatoes, peppers, eggplant | 30 to 50% | 22 to 30 |
| Cucumbers, melons, squash | 30 to 50% | 20 to 30 |
| Strawberries | 30 to 40% | 17 to 22 |
| Lettuce and salad greens | 50 to 60% | 12 to 17 |
| Spinach, kale, chard | 40 to 60% | 12 to 17 |
| Herbs, basil | 30 to 50% | 12 to 20 |
| Seedlings and transplants | 50 to 60% | 10 to 14 |
| Rooting cuttings | 70 to 80% | 4 to 8 |
| Geraniums and bedding flowers | 30 to 50% | 12 to 20 |
| Orchids, phalaenopsis | 70 to 80% | 4 to 6 |
| Ferns and shade foliage | 70 to 80% | 3 to 6 |
What shade percentage should you buy if you can only buy one?
Fifty percent, in almost every case. It is the setting that suits fruiting crops through their hottest weeks without costing them yield, it is survivable for greens, and it is the most widely stocked rating so replacements are easy to find. The BELLEBILL 50 Percent Shade Cloth, 10 x 12 ft is the standard hobby size with grommets already fitted, which matters because cloth without grommets tears at every tie point within a season.
Buy the second one for propagation rather than for the house. A small piece of 70 percent cloth over a cuttings bench, under the 50 percent covering the roof, gives roughly 85 percent total shade on that bench alone, which is the correct figure for unrooted material, without darkening the tomatoes.
A seasonal shading schedule
| Season | Typical outside DLI | Action | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deep winter | 5 to 15 mol/m2/day | No shade at all, clean the glazing | Inside DLI can fall under 5, which is below the minimum for lettuce, so every percent of transmission counts. |
| Late winter into spring | 15 to 30 | No shade, but watch seedlings | Light climbs faster than temperature. Young transplants scorch on a bright cold day with the vents shut. |
| Late spring | 30 to 45 | Put 50 percent on the roof | This is when a closed house starts exceeding 95 degrees F, which is where tomato pollen viability drops. |
| High summer | 45 to 60 | Keep 50 percent, add 70 percent over propagation | Peak load. Shading is cheaper than any amount of fan capacity for the same temperature reduction. |
| Late summer into autumn | 30 to 45 | Remove propagation shade, keep roof shade | Autumn crops are establishing and still need protection, but light is falling fast. |
| Autumn | 15 to 30 | Remove all shade | Every day it stays on past this point costs winter crops light they cannot get back. |
Shade cloth colors and what they actually do
Black knitted cloth blocks light without changing its spectrum much and is the general-purpose choice. White or aluminized cloth reflects rather than absorbs, so it runs cooler at the cloth itself and reradiates less heat into the house, which makes it the better choice where the cloth sits directly on the glazing. Green cloth transmits proportionally more green light, which plants use least, so it is the least efficient choice for the same nominal percentage.
Aluminized reflective cloth is the most effective at reducing temperature per percent of light blocked, and it is also the most expensive. If the goal is specifically to lower house temperature rather than to protect a crop from scorch, it is worth the difference. If the goal is protecting cuttings, plain black at a higher percentage costs less and does the job.
Shade cloth or whitewash?
Whitewash, meaning a proprietary greenhouse shading paint applied to the glazing, has one genuine advantage: it is cheap per square foot on a large house and needs no fixings. Its disadvantages are that it is all or nothing, it cannot be removed for a cloudy fortnight, it washes off unevenly, and on twin-wall polycarbonate it is hard to remove without scratching. On a hobby greenhouse, cloth wins on nearly every count. The full comparison is in shade cloth versus whitewash.
Shade cloth by percentage
Fixing shade cloth so it survives a season
The fabric almost never fails. The tie points do. Shade cloth is a sail, and a 10 by 20 ft sheet in a 30 mile per hour gust exerts hundreds of pounds of force concentrated at whatever is holding it. Three rules follow. Use every grommet, not every third one. Tie with something that has a little stretch, such as bungee loops or elastic cord, rather than something rigid that transfers the whole shock load into one hole. And tension the sheet properly: a loose cloth that can flap will destroy itself and can scratch polycarbonate as it moves.
On a polycarbonate house the simplest method is a continuous batten along each eave with the cloth trapped under it, and elastic ties down to the frame at intervals. On a film tunnel, running the cloth over the hoops and pinning it at ground level with heavy steel landscape staples works and is easy to remove. Avoid anything that puts a hard point load on the glazing itself.
What shade cloth does not fix
Shade cloth reduces the light and therefore the heat load, and it does not do anything about three related summer problems. Understanding the boundary keeps you from buying more cloth when the problem is elsewhere.
| Symptom | Actual cause | Does shade cloth help? | What does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peak temperature above 100 degF | Solar gain exceeding ventilation capacity | Yes, substantially | Shade first, then exhaust airflow from the CFM chart. |
| Tomato flowers dropping without setting | Pollen non-viable above about 95 degF, or humidity outside 40 to 70 percent | Yes, indirectly | Shade plus ventilation to hold the peak down, plus hand pollination in the morning. |
| Leaf scorch on young transplants | Direct beam light on tissue that cannot transpire fast enough | Yes, this is exactly what it is for | Higher percentage cloth over the propagation bench specifically. |
| Wilting at midday despite wet soil | Transpiration exceeding root uptake, a water transport limit | Partly | Shade reduces demand, but the root cause is usually root volume or salinity. |
| Bitter lettuce and bolting | Temperature and daylength, not light intensity alone | Partly | Shade helps, but bolt-resistant varieties and succession sowing matter more. |
| Blossom end rot on tomatoes | Irregular calcium uptake driven by irregular watering | No | Consistent irrigation, which means a timer and drip rather than hand watering. |
| Spider mite outbreak | Hot dry conditions favor mites over their predators | Slightly | Raising humidity, damping down, and biological control. |
Match the percentage to your latitude and season with the shade cloth calculator, check the light your crop actually needs against the DLI targets chart, see where shade sits in the wider cooling strategy in cooling a greenhouse in summer, and read the fruit-set problem in pollination in a greenhouse.